Wednesday, December 31, 2008

The full penalty of the law

(Note – all the teams named are the current teams of these players at the time of writing)

Only those who have spent the last few days on a different planet will not have heard of Steven Gerrard’s arrest and charge of assault and affray. It will be interesting to see how the authorities deal with such a famous and popular – at least as an international – player. It will be even more interesting to see how a club as prestigious as Liverpool decides to proceed with such a delicate matter.

What is increasingly more mundane, however, is the fact that a professional footballer has fallen foul of the law while showing his true colours. It is something we have come to expect in the last few years, as recent news items show. While Gerrard was “helping police with their enquiries” twenty-year-old Sheffield United player Jordan Robertson was arrested on suspicion of dangerous driving after a father of five was killed in a road accident over Christmas.

Earlier this year we have already seen 25-year-old Newcastle United player Joey Barton sentenced to six months in jail, also for assault and affray (note to Gerrard and the judge who will try his case, if it comes to trial), and 25-year-old Plymouth Argyle player Luke McCormick sentenced to seven years and four months for killing two little children in a car crash. Barton also has previous for night-time road accidents, having injured a pedestrian in 2005.

The football hall of shame has, in recent years, also seen the inclusion of Jermaine Pennant (driving offences), Marlon King (driving offences and two cases of assault, one involving punching a woman), and Glen Johnson and Ben May (shoplifting, of all things).

TO LET THE PUNISHMENT FIT THE CRIME

Luke McCormick was at first suspended by his employers, Plymouth Argyle, then sacked, although the euphemism “contract cancelled by mutual consent” was used in the press. When his friend David Norris – the man whose wedding had provided McCormick with the excuse to go overboard – made the immature and offensive “handcuffs gesture” during a goal celebration and compounded his stupidity by lying about the gesture, his employers Ipswich Town fined him £25,000.

(Some people may also recall Tim Cahill’s “handcuffs gesture” during a goal celebration earlier this year. This was directed at his own brother, who is serving a prison sentence and was meant as a gesture of brotherly support as opposed to one of insolent defiance, although it could also be argued that it may be seen to endorse violence.)

It remains to be seen whether McCormick will be welcomed back into the footballing fold, but the omens, for him at least, are good. Lee Hughes, the 32-year-old Oldham Athletic player, was jailed for six years in August 2004 for killing one person and injuring another in a road accident during the 2003-4 season. Hughes even fled the scene rather than face up to his crime.

Hughes’ employers at the time, West Bromwich Albion, terminated his contract after the player had been sentenced. However, not only was Hughes bailed awaiting trial – allowing him to shrug off any alleged distress and become his club’s top scorer – he was offered a new contract at Oldham Athletic while still in prison. Barton, Pennant, King, Johnson and May still earn the obscene amounts paid to professional footballers of any division, and there is no doubt that Liverpool FC will abandon all pretence of dignity or integrity by continuing to employ Gerrard should he be convicted.

THE DEBT TO SOCIETY

Lee Hughes would argue that he paid the price for his crime – he was convicted of an offence and given a sentence which he served in accordance with the laws of his country – and that those laws state that not only should he not be punished beyond that, but he should be allowed every opportunity to re-enter society on an equal footing with any other citizen. He should certainly not be punished by being refused work simply because of his record.

It is indeed shocking when the holier-than-thou element of our society decides to continue punishing people for mistakes they have made in the past. How can a person be expected to live a decent life if the meagre opportunities they have clung to in the past are now converted into a brick wall of total rejection?

However, there is a clear case in favour of not allowing people to resume certain occupations even after completing sentences, depending on the crime and the occupation. A person convicted of any sort of crime involving children should not be a school teacher, for example. Somebody convicted of fraud should not be allowed to work in government or in any job involving the handling of large amounts of money.

ROLE MODELS

Anybody who has worked with children knows how influential football is on their lives. When a kid has a ball at their feet, they run like their favourite player and celebrate a goal in the same way, even though the goal is scored between two jerseys. In 1986 some of my classmates even came in wearing plaster casts on perfectly healthy arms. Nowadays, of course, children even protest in the same way as their idols, first diving then twisting their faces in perfect imitation.

The point is that they see the actions of their heroes, and the consequences of such actions. Children are not stupid – they are far more intelligent than a lot of people give them credit for. They may or may not think that the actions are acceptable, but they will always take note of a lack of punishment, and incorporate that knowledge into their take on the world.

And subsequently, their take on the world around them and the society they live in will manifest itself in the way they behave towards members of that society. So do we really want to allow the likes of McCormick and Gerrard to be their role models?

Wednesday, December 3, 2008

A lesson in history

Arsenal are enduring troubled times recently. Results in the Premier League so far this season have been unexpectedly poor, leaving the club with no chance of even pretending to compete with United and Chelsea. They have already lost more games than Hull City, and have even lost twice at home. So have Chelsea, of course, but the difference is that they at least look like title contenders.

In the Champions League their position appears to be stronger, but they have hardly convinced against average opposition, needing a highly biased referee – note the difference in the free kicks which led to Arsenal’s goal and Dinamo Kiev’s red card – to earn qualification without needing to win their last game. Chelsea have yet to impress either – but again they look more likely finalists.

Off the pitch things are hardly any better. William Gallas was photographed supposedly leaving a nightclub with a cigarette in his mouth, prompting sadly predictable references to Clinton. Gallas compounded his alleged sin by deigning to have an opinion on the team he captains – indirectly hinting at the reasons for the problems – thus inviting the ire of a manager who has always gone to ridiculous lengths to pretend his players are perfect.

Gallas’ replacement as captain is a highly unpopular youngster with no obvious leadership skills who has yet to demonstrate his mettle under the greatest pressure. And talking of youngsters, the teams fielded in the Carling Cup add more fuel to the fire by playing so well in a trophy already devalued by the likes of Arsenal that there are suggestions that they should replace the first team in the Premier League.

And perhaps the worst aspect of this crisis of confidence is the fact that record numbers of Arsenal fans are calling for Wenger’s head. Actually, no, the worst thing of all is the number of fans bleating about how this could possibly be happening in such a historic club.

A SENSE OF HISTORY

What do these fans mean when they talk about a historic club? Taking into account that most people do not know the exact difference between the words “historic” and “historical”, are they referring to the club’s history? Obviously every club has a history – it’s everything that has happened before today. Even teams that have never won anything have a past. Even MK Dons.

Are they trying to suggest that their club is older than most? Arsenal was founded in 1886, by which time dozens of clubs already existed in England alone. Age alone would make Prescot Cables a historic club.

Let’s face it, history means trophies, the only reason that clubs put teams out every week. And in that respect, Arsenal are simply a bunch of arrivistes.

NEW BOYS IN TOWN

Arsenal have won five league titles, five FA cups, one League Cup and the European Cup-Winners’ Cup – a fine haul indeed, but all won in the last twenty years. Before all that, Arsenal were just another run-of-the-mill team, except during a brief moment in time in the 1930s when they won another five titles and two FA cups. By the same token, Huddersfield Town dominated one decade, winning three league titles and an FA cup in the twenties – does that make them historic too?

For the rest of their existence, Arsenal were habitual runners-up who occasionally won the odd trophy. Most clubs manage to win the odd trophy, even if it is some random cup, including Leicester City, Norwich City and Luton Town. Even Sunderlandnil have won stuff.

Some may retort that United’s only period of dominance before the Ferguson years was from the late fifties to the late sixties, with the Munich tragedy causing a desperately unfortunate pause in that supremacy. However, at least during those glorious years United did manage to make history.

ONE OF THE FAMILY

There are, of course, other ways of interpreting the definition of the word “historic”. There is no doubt that there are certain clubs around England that have had a considerable “importance on or influence in” history, albeit in a more local sense. There is absolutely no denying, for example, the contribution that Newcastle United have made to the local community in the north-east.

The same can hardly be said of Arsenal, who are just another London team, and not even the only team in their area. Their brand-new stadium carries the name of a foreign country, not a local street or neighbourhood. Their fans are regarded as either non-participatory (as in “the Highbury Library”), members of the prawn sandwich brigade or people in distant countries whose favourite sons have managed to impress Wenger enough to secure a place in the team.

YOU’RE HISTORY

This is one of the unfortunate side effects of young fans jumping on the bandwagon of a club’s temporary success. I can remember when nobody had ever heard of Arsenal; kids nowadays only remember Wenger’s trophies. Arsenal fans like to look down on Chelsea fans as upstarts, people who support a club which has bought success and that only in recent seasons.

How conveniently they forget that that describes Arsenal fans of ten years ago to perfection.

And now that the Arsenal “faithful” are baying for Wenger’s blood, perhaps it is appropriate to mention the anti-climax being experienced at the club. The manager that many consider to be a genius appeared to be slowly but surely building up to a period of total European domination – yet when they finally stepped up to the stage, they were found wanting. And they have won nothing since.

Indeed it must be said that the overriding impression which comes from Arsenal today is that their years of success are now no more than history. Perhaps that’s what the fans mean.